It all starts with will
Saturday, 28 April 2007 | 268 readers so far
Some people have a will to live and some a will to die. The stronger of the two will usually win when they come into conflict. In the case of the Virginia Tech massacre, the students who died were in a state of conflict with an armed lunatic. His will was much more powerful than theirs.
And the Washington Post carried a story citing students who had been in the classrooms that were attacked. “I quickly dove under a desk,†Clay Violand, a Virginia Tech junior, told the Post. “That was the desk I chose to die under.â€
Violand listened as the gunman began “methodically and calmly†shooting people. “It sounded rhythmic-like. He took his time between each shot and kept up the pace, moving from person to person.†After every shot, Violand said he thought to himself, “Okay, the next one is me.†But shot after shot, and he felt nothing. He played dead.
“The room was silent except for the haunting sound of moans, some quiet crying, and someone muttering: ‘It’s OK. It’s going to be OK. They will be here soon,’ †he recalled. “The gunman circled again and seemed to be unloading a second round into the wounded. Violand thought he heard the gunman reload three times.â€
Marc Danzinger thinks doctrine is to blame for the slaughter.
Similarly, the discussions around the responses of the students seem to imply those of us who are suggesting the students could have done other things that may have changed the outcome are blaming the students.
No, we’re not. We’re blaming the doctrine the victims were trained to operate under, and arguing that we — all of us — should rethink it and start implementing other ones, just as airline passengers and police officers have.
We need to be teaching people a new doctrine, one that neither leads them into fantasies that they are more capable than they really are, nor into believing that they are helpless and must lay down waiting to be killed while muttering “It’s OK. It’s going to be OK. They will be here soon.â€
I am going to pound this into peoples’ heads, because few others seem willing. One guy, two guns. Reloads three times. Not one student attacks during the reloading. Come on. You pick up something heavy, and you smash him in the face with it. If just 10% of the students being murdered had that kind of will, that kind of determination, then the number of victims would have been much lower. Yes, I’m insensitive. Get over it. If being insensitive causes even one person to stand up for his or her own existence during a moment of crisis it will be worth it.
There are two survival choices in situations of life and death conflict, fight or flight. We need to teach our citizens both options so that they are not paralyzed and helpless in times of unexpected crisis.












Kristi,
I dare because it’s what I do. I ask questions other people are afraid of touching.
Sorry if you lost someone to violence. You clearly didn’t look around this blog long enough before you posted your emotional response. Read a few of the entries from a year ago, and you will realize that I have been a soldier in Iraq. I know exactly how I will react to situations that require reaction. I may not prevail, but I know I’ll act.
I believe in making my own luck whenever possible. Perhaps that is part of what makes me insensitive. It’s a survival trait.
I’m glad Clay lived and I hope he uses his experience to become something more than he otherwise would have become.
Reply to TrevorClay Violand is the brother of one of my best friends. How dare you suggest that those students could have or should have done anything differently? You are correct, you are insensitive. No one can truly know how they would react in a given situation until you have actually been in that situation. It’s easy to sit in your room at your computer and proclaim the heroic actions you would have provided had you been in that classroom, but in reality, you have no idea what it feels like to face death. Maybe you would have stood up, hit the shooter in the face with a desk and saved the day. Then again, maybe you would have huddle under your desk in fear and waited to die with the rest of your innocent classmates. And if you were lucky like Clay, maybe, just maybe you would have lived to tell about it.
Reply to KristiThis is so tragic because it reminds me of having “deer in the headlights” syndrome - you just freeze you are so shocked….Instead of the countless shows, discussions, what have you, on trying to figure out how the mental case shooter went mental, there should be discussions on how should potential victims act and respond in such a situation. Like you said Trevor, they could have piled desks up against the doors, all kids could have thrown books, backpacks and pens at the guy as soon as he came to their class, four people could have tackled him trying to save the others, etc. I think we are already telling little kids to kick, scream and fight back should someone try to abduct them from their front yard - it is the same thing. Teach how to survive. Just an opinion - thanks.
Reply to LongIslandB