Navigate / search

Obamacare is coming; Congress will opt out

Conn Carroll writes a thought provoking essay on the inevitably upcoming “universal health care” that is going to be rammed down our throats. Most of us are like little birds with our mouths wide open, excited about the free grubs. Me, not so much.

When selling his vision for health care reform to the American people, President-elect Barack Obama promised: “I will establish a new national health plan, similar to the plan available to federal employees and members of Congress, that gives every American the opportunity to buy affordable health coverage.” The Heritage Foundation has long been an advocate for organizing a national health exchange based on the same model that delivers care to members of Congress; the Federal Employees Health Benefits Program (FEHBP).  The problem is that both Obama’s plan, and the plan recently released by Sen. Max Baucus (D-MT), contain key differences from the FEHBP that will completely undermine its success.

Under the FEHBP, national and local private health plans compete on a level playing field for the business of members of Congress and thousands of federal government employees. The FEHBP has relatively few mandated benefits which allows for both more choice in the types of plans available and keeps a lid on costs. The Obama plan in particular moves away from this model by significantly increasing the number of mandated specific benefits all plan most cover. This will send already rising insurance premiums through the roof. Worse, the Obama plan clearly intends to bring price controls into the health care sector. Obama promises Americans will be charged “fair” premiums and “minimal co-pays.” Presumably, Congress would define these terms. This would put the federal government in the business of deciding what constitutes a fair price and a proper co-payment for benefits and ser­vices, leading to some type of centralized rate set­ting or standardization of payments for providers. In the FEHBP, prices are market-based. No price regulation is imposed on plans or services.

The truth of the matter is that Hillary Clinton will always received better health care than her subjects.  Barack Obama has a better chance of surviving cancer or a heart attack than you do. Clinton and Obama have lives that are worth much more than yours. That is how government works. Government, a monopoly on force, naturally protects its own members first.

That is why I have low expectations and a dubious outlook when it comes to “universal” health care. There is no such thing. Different standards will be applied to the elite ruling class. They’ll have better care, more options and fewer treatment limitations.

The government-sponsored health exchange would naturally write the rules of competition to benefit the government plan. Imagine if baseball umpires and the New York Yankees both worked for George Steinbrenner. The Red Sox or Rays wouldn’t stand a chance. If you think a government entrant in the marketplace will not inevitably turn into a monopolistic financial disaster, then we’ve got two failed mortgage financing giants we’d like to sell you.

Responding to a campaign supporter in New Mexico this summer, Obama said, “If I were designing a system from scratch, I would probably go ahead with a single-payer system.” The Obama plan does not scrap our entire health care system in favor of a brand new government-run system, but it is definitely a deliberate first step down that path.

Mentally prepare yourself young people. You are going to grow up in a place where government, not you, will decide what is best for your continued longevity. Your diet, lifestyle choices and possibly any facet of your life that could affect your health are slowly going to be taken away from you and controlled by people who think they know better than you what is good for you. Here comes change whether you want it or not.



I know what you mean trevor.. but somehow.. I am beginning to think that it might not be as bad as I once feared.

Obama has to get this through and after looking at who he is appointing into his cabinent and who he is talking too.. I wonder if the health care plan he has touted will ultimately go through..


@kitanis: Possibly – but Congress isn’t as one-sidedly behind Obama as I thought it was going to be.

Leave a comment


email* (not published)